Masuda v. Mazzei
Landlord-TenantCitation
72 Misc.3d 1209(A)
Court
New York Supreme Court, New York County
Decided
July 21, 2021
Case Summary
Plaintiffs are four rent-stabilized tenants of 75 Hudson Street in Manhattan who brought this action against their landlord. The landlord counterclaimed against one tenant, Masami Masuda, alleging that her alterations to the building constituted a nuisance. The landlord moved for partial summary judgment on its counterclaims, sought a writ of assistance to evict Masuda, a damages hearing, and unpaid rent.
Outcome
Motion granted in part and denied in part.
Legal Significance
This decision addresses the intersection of rent-stabilization protections and landlord nuisance counterclaims based on tenant alterations. The court's ruling clarified the standards for summary judgment on nuisance claims in rent-stabilized tenancies, an area where the law was previously unsettled.