Published Decisions

Notable Cases

The Beltas Law Firm regularly handles cases where the law is not yet settled. Through motion practice and trial, these cases resulted in published judicial decisions that establish or clarify legal precedent — and are cited on Westlaw.

Why Published Decisions Matter

When a court publishes a decision, it becomes part of the legal record that other courts, attorneys, and scholars rely on. Published decisions on Westlaw shape how the law is interpreted and applied in future cases. Having cases published reflects the firm's work on issues of first impression — legal questions where no prior ruling existed.

Masuda v. Mazzei

Landlord-Tenant

Citation

72 Misc.3d 1209(A)

Court

New York Supreme Court, New York County

Decided

July 21, 2021

Case Summary

Plaintiffs are four rent-stabilized tenants of 75 Hudson Street in Manhattan who brought this action against their landlord. The landlord counterclaimed against one tenant, Masami Masuda, alleging that her alterations to the building constituted a nuisance. The landlord moved for partial summary judgment on its counterclaims, sought a writ of assistance to evict Masuda, a damages hearing, and unpaid rent.

Outcome

Motion granted in part and denied in part.

Legal Significance

This decision addresses the intersection of rent-stabilization protections and landlord nuisance counterclaims based on tenant alterations. The court's ruling clarified the standards for summary judgment on nuisance claims in rent-stabilized tenancies, an area where the law was previously unsettled.

J.M v. M.F.

Landlord-Tenant

Citation

77 Misc.3d 1213(A)

Court

New York County Family Court

Decided

December 12, 2022

Case Summary

This family offense proceeding was brought under Article 8 of the Family Court Act. The respondent moved to dismiss the petition on the grounds that the court lacked subject matter jurisdiction, and also sought sanctions and attorneys' fees. The central question was whether roommates who have no additional relationship outside of the roommate context can seek protections in family court.

Outcome

The court granted the motion in part, ruling that roommates with no relationship beyond the roommate context cannot seek protections in family court.

Legal Significance

This decision established new law on the scope of Family Court jurisdiction under Article 8 of the Family Court Act. The court defined the limits of who qualifies for family court protections — holding that a pure roommate relationship, without any additional intimate, familial, or household-member relationship, falls outside the court's subject matter jurisdiction. This ruling provides important guidance for practitioners on jurisdictional questions in family offense proceedings.

Facing an Unsettled Legal Question?

When the law is unclear, you need an attorney willing to take the issue head-on. Schedule an initial consultation to discuss your case.

Schedule Initial Consultation

Important Notice: The case summaries on this page are for informational purposes only and do not constitute legal advice. Case outcomes depend on specific facts and circumstances. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome in future cases.

BELTASLAW

Protecting tenants and consumers across New York, California, and Washington D.C.

Contact

© 2026 Beltas Law. All rights reserved.

Attorney Advertising. This website is designed for general information only. The information presented should not be construed as formal legal advice or the formation of an attorney-client relationship. Results depend on individual circumstances. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. Licensed in New York, California, and Washington D.C.

Call Now - Initial Consultation